16 Comments

In his book 1917 Barry White the Israeli scholar identifies huge swathes of 'Palestinians' with Arabic names denoting family birth origins in countries far removed from Palestine. What about a paper: 'Family origins and Palestinian identity'? Few takers because that study would ruthlessly expose the Arab invader scenario.

Expand full comment

oooops. That's Barry Shaw.

Expand full comment

Here's the link.

Expand full comment

https://www.amazon.com.au/1917-Palestine-Extraordinary-Struggles-Christian/dp/154230010X

Another interesting observation made by Barry Shaw is the establishment of the Jewish Workers Union in 1920 - David Ben Gurion was its first secretary. Why a trade union then? It was because of the huge influx of Arabs seeking work in the newly-established industries in Palestine.

Expand full comment

Thanks for the suggestion. Bought it.

Expand full comment

You can edit your comments. Press the three dots at the right. Doesn’t work from the app, I’m told.

Expand full comment

Thanks for the tip!

I think you will find the book enlightening.

Expand full comment

"In contemporary media language, the land of Israel is often mistakenly referred to as 'Palestine.' Let me point out that it is totally contrary to Biblical truth to call it Palestine. Palestine means the land of the Philistines. That term was never used until the Romans had conquered and destroyed the second temple. Then they used the name Palestine to assert that the Jews no longer had any claim to this region. It was a deliberately chosen anti-Semitic word. Biblically, the land of Israel was called the land of Canaan before it was taken by Joshua. But in the New Testament, do you know what this nation was called? The land of Israel. "Why Israel? God's Heart for a People, His Plan for a Nation," Derek Prince (Genesis 17:7-8, Psalm 105:7-11, Jeremiah 30:3)

Expand full comment

How about a study that asks why early to mid twenty first century white and and Jewish women raised with the most wealth and comfort ever known to human kind hate themselves?

Expand full comment

They have been taught to hate themselves.

Expand full comment

White and Jewish men have enjoyed the same comforts--and are just as prone to White Guilt, Leftism, and paying lip service (and more) to Woke in the name of career stability.

Expand full comment

It's this type of deranged "woke" insanity which the American electorate thoroughly rejected.

Expand full comment

Hey Joe.. i dont have an answer to your question.. But i do have an answer as to why Israel is Israel.. Back in 1914, the Ottoman Empire big bosses decided to align with Germany against Russia.. Germany lost that war.. Now along comes WW2.. Ottoman empire was forced to align with Germany again..And they lost again.. Reparations... The Jews that Germany tried to exterminate were provided with a "forever home".. So if you want to blame anyone, blame the ??? Ottoman Empire guys who made a very poor decision in 1914.. I really advise people to read.. before they start to write......

Expand full comment

"I really advise people to read before they start to write." Yes!!!

Expand full comment

The Ottoman collapsed shortly after the war. Republic of Turkey as of 1923.

But they did ally themselves with the losing side in WW 1.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ottoman_Empire

Expand full comment

Just teachings of Demons opposed to God;s purposes in the land He gave the Children of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob and opposed to the promises to Israel which do not change.

Expand full comment