Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Phyllis Chesler's avatar

From email:

Sadly politics and religion control our lives. Your opus is far from impartial, but there can be no impartiality when it comes to religion.

God made us, and all animals competitive. Read the Torah: right there in Genesis IV 8. "Now Cain said to his brother Abel, “Let's go out to the field. While they were in the field, Cain attacked his brother Abel and killed him,"

The Torah understands human nature. Humans are jealous and vicious. More than animals. In fact, there is no mention of animals fighting with each other - only humans.

Survival of the fittest - but how do you get to be the fittest? According to the Torah, you kill the opposition.

This theme repeats over and over in the Torah - just consider the drowning of the Egyptians in Exodus - the story could have been written without that episode and have the same conclusion. But the Torah is true to human nature and so Abel's murder is included.

And so is the mass murder of the Egyptians by GOD!

And just consider that the slaves who were escaping from Egypt, the descendants of Jacob, were not yet Jews - that doesn't happen until Mt Sinai.

So violence is an essential part of the Torah narrative, and I believe that that is because violence is a human characteristic.

So: What of Iran? Is killing for a good cause better than killing for a bad cause?

Ask the parents and children and spouses of the dead.

One more thing: Consider why the Torah includes all of the violence in Genesis. It could have started the narrative with Mt Sinai.

I believe it's there for a reason. And that reason is to make us feel less bad about ourselves and our emotions. Yes we are animals, but we are also humans. And although it is the human aspect of our being that we must cultivate, the Torah reassures us that bad things happen.

Happy Pesach

Phyllis Chesler's avatar

From email:

 Dear Phyllis,

I’ve been away, dealing with some problems of my own, and now trying to catch up with this Iran & Hamas situation. Thanks -- deep, deepest thanks! -- for providing the only note of recognizable reality in anything I’ve found to read so far!

Bless you — & please keep well!

Your loving & admiring friends

5 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?