Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Feather Duster's avatar

I appreciate this letter to your old friend Esther, and learning about this wonderful ritual group you were part of creating. I feel envious--and sorrowful that I know of no such ritual or ceremony groups today despite hearing the almost continuous command from my own inner self to start one for many many years, for decades now since I was lucky enough to be a part of some earlier in my life, Los Angeles; Maria Gimbutas; Riane Eisler; Gloria Orenstein; Ruth Barrett and Starhawk-style, evoking The Great Goddess for our common inspiration and protection. I hear your poignant apology here as a clarion call to contemporary women's rights campaigners, organizers, activists and groups of supporters to imagine a future where many if not most of us let our fierce friendships and playful camaraderies fracture, fall away, shatter, explode and be gone from our lives, and the regret we will feel as we each live our lives after it, missing the days when we were swept together by a current of Woman Power that answered the call for protecting Women and Girls from the dangers that so many men threaten us with. Hopefully, God willing we are successful, we will be remembered as though we are still one movement, all together, always together, and sharing victories over the tyrannies of patriarchy, elitism, and the organizations out to crush the entire sex-binary of human beings in the name of greed. P.S. Of all the books you referred to in this letter, by you or Esther or others in your group, which describes, if any, the kinds of rituals and ceremonies you did, specifically, that we might revive and do today? If none, would you write one? Thank you. Thank you for keeping your oars in the water still today. It is a gift to us all. I'm almost 70, and there are plenty around my age, but most of the activist women are younger younger and younger still, all still 'divided' on what feminism IS, and ISN'T; some suggesting feminism 'is over' and being supplanted by 'we are an island' youth.

Leigh Halprin's avatar

"Jewish Arabs" Did I read that right? I had to revisit that descriptor and

then read it again. Yes. That is indeed what you wrote. Phyllis, there is no

such thing in the real world as “Jewish Arabs.”There are Jews and there are

Arabs. And there are Jews that lived in what are now Arab countries. But I

repeat, there are no "Jewish Arabs". Our people lived in the Levant for at

least 1600 to 1800 years before Arab expansion and settlement from the Arab

Peninsula in the 7th century CE. As for your romantic identification with

"Jewish Arabs" wandering and picnicking in the desert, our 40 years was between

the late 15th century BCE or 13th century BCE, long before any Arab set a

toenail in the Sinai.

We did not lose our identity and become "Jewish Arabs" because of Arab

invaders. Further, under Islamic rule, Jewish populations living in MENA

were categorized as dhimmi, a legally subordinate and inferior minority to

Muslims rather than as Arabs.

This is not pedanticism. The term" Jewish Arabs" is sometimes used to

minimize our indigeneity to Israel or to reframe Jewish displacement from

Arab countries. Shana Tova.

1 more comment...

Ready for more?